The Effectiveness of the Placebo

In Lawrence LeShan's book, Alternate Realities: Theattack, the doctor administered a placebo however,
Search for the Full Human Being, he says, "A reality isthe patient's condition did not change. This result
real to you when you act in terms of it... It is a validserved as evidence to the doctor that the new drug
reality when, using it, you can accomplish the goalswas indeed quite effective. To his amazement he
acceptable to it." The effects of internal thoughts aslater received a letter from the drug's manufacturer
a valid reality are often most evident with miraculousstating that they had shipped out the placebo instead
cases of healing attributed to the placebo effect orof the actual medication. So, the patient had never
suggestions given during hypnosis.truly received the new drug. He had only been
The word placebo is Latin for "I shall please." Oftenexposed to the doctor's enthusiasm. This type of
called a sugar pill, its pharmaceutical effects arescenario led James McCormick to state, "The
considered innocuous. The power of the placebo isphysician's belief in the treatment and the patient's
found in the belief system of the one receiving it. Infaith in the physician exert a mutually reinforcing
blind studies which test the effectiveness of a neweffect; the result is a powerful remedy that is almost
medication, doctor's often administer the actualguaranteed to produce an improvement and
medication to one half of the group under study andsometimes a cure."
administer a placebo to the other half, often calledWhile some of the research concerning the placebo
the control group. While these types of studies haveeffect credits the results of this treatment to the
been considered reliable for decades, in 2000body's incredible ability to heal itself, most researchers
researchers from the University of Copenhagen andattribute the improved condition of the patients and
the Nordic Cochrane Center in Denmark added a neweven their complete healing to psychological effects
twist to the process. They administered drugs tobrought to bear by the patient's own beliefs.
part of the group, placebos to another part of theIn an effort to show just how much control the mind
group and only monitored the actual control group. Ofhas over the condition of the body, Talbot cites the
those receiving the placebo, about 35% were cured.unusual medical conditions of folks who have multiple
This has been the statistical norm since the firstpersonality disorders. In one such case, all but one of
studies in the mid 1950s. What was significant aboutthe sub-personalities, or alters, of a certain patient
this new test was that the same percentage of theimmediately broke out in an allergic rash when
control group was also cured. Recall that the controlexposed to orange juice. The non-allergic personality
group received no medication and no placebo. Theircould drink all the orange juice he wanted with no
progress was only monitored. However, that sameside-effect whatsoever. He also referred to case
study did find that those receiving the placebostudies which showed that drug dosage was
reported less pain than the control group.especially problematic among adult multiples who had
Researchers who have specifically studied thechildren as alters. If they were given an adult dosage
placebo effect have often run into difficulty whenof a medication, they could immediately begin to
properly assessing their statistics. The problem is thatsuffer an overdose reaction when a child personality
the effect has everything to do with the subjectivetook over.
and personally unique attitude and belief system ofOne of the most amazing facts Talbot points out in
the patient. In some cases, a patient who exhibits nohis comments about multiples is that they are difficult
confidence in the treatment they are receiving willto anesthetize. He states, "There are accounts of
manifest a negative physical reaction to the placebo.multiples waking up on the operating table after one
In effect, they show signs of side-effects to an inertof their non-anesthetizable sub-personalities has taken
substance. This is called the nocebo effect.over." What makes this an amazing feat is that it
In the last few decades, research conducted on newbrings into question the function of the brain as being
trial medications are most often conducted as athe sole source of the mind. If the brain rules the
double-blind study. This means that neither the doctorbody and the patient's brain is chemically rendered
nor the patient know if they are receiving the actualunconscious, how could they switch to a personality
medication or the placebo. The reason for thisthat is completely awake?
condition is that researchers found that often timesTalbot also cites that some research has been
the doctor's attitude toward the medication beingconducted showing that multiples exhibit different
administered affected the patient's attitude towardbrainwave patterns from one another. This evidence
the treatment. In his book, The Holographic Universe,is highly controversial, mainly because it brings so
author Michael Talbot cites a story told by placebomany metaphysical questions to the forefront. Do
specialist Dr. David Sobel, of a doctor treating histhe auric fields and thought-forms surrounding a
asthma patient with a new trial drug. He told theperson play a significant role in how the body
patient that this drug was particularly potent andfunctions? Where exactly is the mind located and
would clear up the breathing problems. Within minuteswhat is the source of consciousness? These are just
of administration, the patient's condition improvedsome of the questions researchers of many
dramatically. Later, when the patient suffered anotherdisciplines are trying to figure out.